“Those who refer to women as 'incubators' don't want to discuss anything” – Brosius-Gersdorf attacks the Union
German constitutional law professor Frauke Brosius-Gersdorf has strongly criticized members of the conservative Union (CDU/CSU), saying meaningful debate becomes impossible when women are described as "incubators" in discussions about reproductive rights.
Her comments come amid an intense political dispute involving the Union and former parliamentary leader Jens Spahn, as debates over abortion, constitutional law, and judicial appointments continue to dominate German politics. Brosius-Gersdorf argued that reducing women to their reproductive role undermines respectful democratic discussion and distracts from the legal and ethical issues at the center of the debate.
The professor defended her legal positions and rejected claims made by some conservative critics about her views. She emphasized that complex constitutional questions deserve factual and evidence-based discussion rather than emotional rhetoric or personal attacks. According to her, public discourse should focus on legal principles instead of inflammatory language.
The controversy has intensified as Germany continues to debate judicial appointments and broader social issues. Political disagreements over abortion policy and constitutional interpretation have increasingly become part of a wider ideological confrontation between progressive and conservative forces in the country.
Despite the heated exchanges, Brosius-Gersdorf insisted she remains committed to open democratic dialogue. However, she warned that productive discussion becomes impossible when opponents rely on provocative slogans instead of addressing the substance of constitutional arguments, adding that respectful debate is essential for maintaining trust in Germany's democratic institutions.