Nicaragua hands over Evelyn Rayo murder suspect to US
Published
Nicaragua handed over a man accused of killing Evelyn Rayo Mairena, and a US court set his bail at four million dollars. For Nicaraguans, the case raises a legal question, because article 39 of the Nicaraguan Constitution bans extraditing nationals. Douglas José Centeno Vargas appeared before a judge in Connecticut on 18 November 2026.
The victim was a 24-year-old Nicaraguan woman, and she was shot in front of her one-year-old daughter. On the night of 21 October 2025, police found Rayo Mairena on Black Avenue. Centeno Vargas faces three charges: murder, endangering a minor and tampering with physical evidence.
According to the Bridgeport Police (Policía de Bridgeport), the suspect had fled to Nicaragua after the crime. The police confirmed the transfer and the arrest on 18 November 2026. The US Marshals Service (Servicio de Alguaciles de Estados Unidos) flew him from Nicaragua to Texas several weeks before the announcement.
On 17 November, Bridgeport detectives took him from the Montgomery County jail near Houston to the police headquarters in the city. Detective Jeffrey Holtz said Centeno Vargas had been in Nicaraguan custody since mid-2026. That custody followed a search in which the marshals and Interpol, the international police agency, worked together. Holtz credited part of the result to pressure from the victim's family on Nicaraguan authorities.
Holtz said the government of Daniel Ortega and Rosario Murillo proposed trying Centeno Vargas in Nicaragua. The proposal reached the Bridgeport prosecutor's office (Fiscalía) through the US State and Justice Departments. The prosecutors rejected it. Centeno Vargas stayed in Nicaraguan custody for several months, until the authorities allowed the US marshals to take charge of him. The police called the handover an extradition.
Holtz said the two countries have no extradition treaty. However, a bilateral treaty signed in 1905 appears on a US House of Representatives list of active agreements. The police did not say which legal process allowed the handover.
The case now continues before the court in Connecticut. The details were first reported by Despacho 505.
Source: Despacho 505
Sources: Despacho 505